Turn off the Lights

The Flash – Welcome to Earth-2 Review

"Kind of garbage."

I never expected to be so frustrated with The Flash. Since the beginning of the season, I have written about the same issues week after week, and week after week I write about the little bit of hope I have for the next episode. There’s always something that makes it look like the series is just about to get better, and to stop feeling like I’m being negative about the show for the sake of it, I go, “Maybe that’ll do the trick. Maybe that’ll turn it all around.” In the case of “Welcome to Earth-2,” I thought Team Flash taking the fight to another world would be it. But while the change in scenery did make for some fun moments, their insistence on mischaracterizing Barry to create conflict and emotional resonance completely ruined the episode.

Cisco Ramon - The Flash
Photo: Diyah Pera/The CW — © 2016 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved.

Heads shaking, let’s go deeper.

The whole, “becoming emotionally attached to people in another world,” thing was just stupid. I understand why they wanted to show Barry hesitating before engaging Earth-2’s Caitlin Snow (Killer Frost), but making him appeal to her, outing himself in the process, was absurd. He knows they’re looking for a breacher. He should know they’re working for Zoom. How could he possibly think that that was a good idea? Again, I understand why they would want there to be some internal conflict here, but inflating Barry’s “heart over head” mentality to drive the episode (instead of being relegated to a character beat) was yet another instance of The Flash making Barry Allen seem incredibly dumb. And that wasn’t even the worst part. When Harry says that Killer Frost and Deathstorm knowing Barry’s on Earth-2 means it’s “not long before Zoom does to, and then [his] daughter’s dead,” Barry says, “Jesse still has time, okay?” I’m sorry, what? The entire point of them all going there was to save Jesse. Didn’t you say something like, “I can’t just give up on [Jesse],” at the end of last week’s episode? This show is so stupid.

I lied about that being the worst part, though. The real worst part of this whole arc is Barry’s reason for not going after Jesse: Joseph (Earth-2 Joe West) dying. “She is Iris, okay? She is to me. No matter what universe I’m in, they are my family. I would think by now you would get how important family is,” he says. First of all, they’re not your family, and the episode doesn’t do enough to explain why he would think this despite the differences. Second, it’s your fault Joseph got injured! For nothing! Not only are you going to stand on a soapbox for a family that isn’t yours (Earth-2 Barry was probably still in the room, unconscious), but you’re going to take Joseph’s last words away from him and comfort his grieving wife? As Jean Henegan said about Arrow (with a more positive twist), this show “drives me absolutely nuts,” and that’s putting it lightly.

Detective Iris West - The Flash
Photo: Diyah Pera/The CW — © 2016 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved

Continuing down the rabbit hole, everyone has been misused as an odd source of conflict or humor this season, but as the origin of most of the show’s comedy Cisco has suffered particular abuse. In “Welcome to Earth-2,” he is afforded some genuinely funny moments and given a potential new storyline that centers on his powers, but he also gets preoccupied with looking for his doppelganger while someone else’s life is at stake. His neglect made me feel the same frustration that I almost perpetually do because of Barry this season, and this was made worse when they had Cisco try to appeal to Ronnie like they did with Barry and Killer Frost (probably to make that response seem more realistic and interesting).

Killer Frost, Deathstorm - The Flash
Photo: Diyah Pera/The CW — © 2016 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved.

A big part of the fun for an alternate universe story like “Welcome to Earth-2” lies in the differences and similarities between the worlds and how the characters react to them. To the show’s credit, the changes never felt too excessive (even though some were just like, “okay?”), and I actually enjoyed how Barry and Cisco reacted to Henry Hewitt’s more pleasant personality.

However, some of the changes weren’t bold enough. The villains of this episode were many, but none of them were very substantial. Killer Frost was kind of fun, seeing Cisco as the fully-fledged metahuman, Reverb, was interesting, and I enjoyed Zoom taking out both him and Deathstorm, but there was a sameness to the personalities of the Earth-2 villains compared to their Earth-1 counterparts that made the trip to Earth-2 seem less significant. I’m not saying Tom Cavanagh does a perfect job, but I enjoy the way he changes it up so that Harry can be seen as different from Harrison Wells, and not just Tom Cavanagh playing him as slightly more abrasive.

Killer Frost - The Flash
Photo: Diyah Pera/The CW — © 2016 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved.

To talk about the true menace of Earth-2, Zoom, I thought it was kind of weak that he employed lackeys and was terrorizing the city. An obsession with speed is one thing, but being the head honcho of a cute supervillain gang seems sort of…beneath him? Right now I’m wondering about his endgame, and if there isn’t one, I want that to be more of the point.

Geomancer, meanwhile, seemed kind of unnecessary. Adam Stafford played the role a little too hammy for my tastes, and the way his character bailed after being shot at so that he could return in the next episode was weak. I really like that Jay is becoming more proactive in the series after being a benchwarmer for so long (especially with pretty hilarious lines like “My pride and my body [are hurt]. Pride and my body”), but I think I would have preferred if more time had been spent on developing Earth-2.

Talking about Jay a little more, it’s hard to predict what’s going to happen in this series – and not in the good way. Previously I mentioned there wasn’t a need for Zoom to have Harry if he was able to take Jay’s speed, but at the time I thought it was just another of the The Flash‘s inconsistencies. However, it was revealed that Jay had actually lost his speed by taking previous iterations of the Velocity-6 formula we last saw in “Legends of Today.” This was characterization Jay desperately needed, and an answer that was long past due. It was funny for Caitlin saying “looks like the Velocity-7 is working” to be so closely followed by Jay wiping out, but they’re no doubt saving him successfully regaining his speed for the next episode.

Unfortunately, the best part of the episode was probably Barry, Harry, and Cisco’s departure from Earth-1. Hearing Barry say, “I know what I have here. I love my life. I love my job, being the Flash. I love you and Joe,” was like a love letter to fans who appreciated the show’s more light-hearted and fun take on the superhero genre. I was obviously proven wrong later, but at the time I thought it might be a sign of the series getting back on track. Everyone saying their goodbyes made me feel similarly, as the team was allowed to be just that – a team. Joe told Harry that he hoped he got his daughter back, and Harry replied, “I’ll make sure you get your son back.” For someone who has been consistently annoyed by Joe’s overreactions to Harry’s very existence, this felt like a nice little mea culpa.

Singing Joseph West - The Flash
Photo: Diyah Pera/The CW — © 2016 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved.

The Flash continues to perplex me. The inbuilt joys of journeying to a new world and discovering the differences led to a pretty enjoyable first half, but then the episode found a way to undercut all the good it had done by sabotaging Barry’s character. I don’t like to get down a series so much, especially when I remember embracing it for all its flaws in the first season, but it’s getting to the point where I would much rather keep the TV off on Tuesday nights. Luckily, though, Better Call Saul is just around the corner.

Your attention is better deserved there.

Cisco Ramon (Carlos Valdez) - The Flash
Pictured: Carlos Valdes as Cisco Ramon — Photo: Diyah Pera/The CW — © 2016 The CW Network, LLC. All rights reserved.

The Slowpokes:

  • Stuff seen in the space between Earth-1 and 2: A different version of Green Arrow who may have a robotic arm (according to IGN), John Wesley Shipp’s Flash, Melissa Benoist’s Supergirl (it would have been bonkers if they hadn’t announced the crossover prior to this), Gorilla Grodd, Jonathon Schaech’s Jonah Hex, and a Legion of Superheroes ring (just like Geoff Johns promised).
  • I can’t believe they found a way to bring Patty up again. That said, I had more of a problem with this in concept than in practice, and it didn’t affect my opinion of the episode.
  • Cisco giving Caitlin a note for his parents and brother was a nice moment for the character. It actually felt warranted and natural, a note which the series hasn’t always been able to hit with Cisco.
  • Cisco trying to say, “You can run, but you can’t hide,” again was awesome.
  • I can’t believe Killer Frost said, “God, this is making me so hot.” A pun about being horny. Wow.
  • “No, I was…I was just…nearby” felt like the laziest way of explaining Wally’s appearance in the episode.
  • I can’t believe Jay punching his helmet was an attack.
  • They really should have gotten on making a cure for Jay sooner. Half the season is a little too long to be dying in silence.
  • To expand on the episode not doing enough to explain why he would consider the Earth-2 Wests his family, the show doesn’t give us that moment of intimacy to make us understand why Barry would overlook them not knowing him and him not knowing them. It would have been much more compelling if Barry began the episode being cold to people he thinks he knows, trying to take Harry’s advice to not get “sucked in emotionally” to heart, but later being confused by their similarities to the people he loves. Maybe one of them confides in him. As it was, this was replaced by them pulling the mom card (again), and the show demonstrated it wouldn’t even be interested in my above suggestion when Barry says, “no matter what universe I’m in, they’re my family,” like he would risk everything for the Iris of Earth-2. Weak stuff, Flash.
  • So weird that Detective West, Floyd “Deadshot” Lawton, and Cisco just dropped their weapons when approached by Killer Frost and Deathstorm. Seemed like they had some kind of plan at first.
  • I don’t understand why Barry asked Cisco, “That didn’t hurt you, did it?” when he tased Bartholomew himself and felt nothing.
  • Barry’s Matrix dodge to allow for the camera to move over to Reverb was a joke.
  • When I first saw the kid(?) with the mask, I thought it was Star-Lord. Actually pretty curious about what this other person is doing there and who they are.
  • If you’re serious about getting your superhero fix but want to quit The Flash, I would suggest checking out Supergirl. I’m not going to say it’s an amazing series, but I enjoyed its 8th episode more than pretty much anything The Flash has put out this season (with the exception of “The Fury of Firestorm,” maybe).

All images via ComicBook.com. Dialogue checked using transcripts.foreverdreaming.org.

Rating
4.0
Pros
  • Star-kid
  • Some fun, "look at how different this place is!" moments
  • Jay being more proactive
  • The departure from Earth-1
Cons
  • Barry and Cisco's collective brain cell
  • Disappointing villains, particularly Geomancer

Liked this article? Try These!

Comments

  • Irish Jim

    I agree that Supergirl is developing nicely. They have the problem that they pit Supergirl against seemingly insurmountable odds and Superman doesn’t help. They have a dozen or so Kyptonians attacking Earth, more than enough to overpower her and Superman takes no interest. They also have not displayed J’onn J’onzz powers very well. He was easily defeated by Kara’s Aunt, which should not have happened.
    I also think Legends of Tomorrow is pretty good. Not great, but pretty good.
    I really don’t like what Flash is doing with Earth 2. I don’t know how comics depict Earth 2 over the last 25 years, but in the 1960s and 1970s it was an earth that was about 20 years behind Earth 1. This Earth 2 looks to be more technologically advanced than Earth 1 – which is a departure.
    Earth 2 had a full set of heroes – the heroes from the Golden Age of comics. They were colorful, interesting and heroic. Jay Garrick was one, but they had Alan Scott’s Green Lantern, Dr. Fate, Hourman, Starman, Dr. Mid-Nite (the first blind superhero), Wildcat, Jonny Thunder, The Specter (probably the most powerful DC hero) and the original Black Canary.
    I would have loved to see one or more of them challenge Zoom.
    Flash has the same problem that the other DC shows (and Agent Carter too) in that they are not telling us what Zoom’s powers are. He is fast. OK. But he killed (did he kill them?) Reverb and Deathstorm like they were powerless. That seems like he is too powerful and not just a speedster.
    I don’t like that all the same charters from Earth 1 are in Earth 2 with wildly different personalities.
    Barry did seem to take Oliver Queen’s stupid pills. He should have gone to the lab, got what he needed and gotten out. Inserting himself into Iris’s life was insane. I hope they don’t have her come to Earth 1 and marry Earth 1 Barry.
    When Joe in Earth 2 died, Earth 2 Barry should have been there, He is Iris’s husband, not Earth 1 Barry. That was idiotic.
    The best thing about his episode was that Jay might get his powers back and save the day. That would be ok.

News from Around the Web

Meet the Author

Follow Us

Our Sponsors

Featured Poll

What is Your Favorite Game Franchise?
Yop Poll Widget
Which Upcoming Game Are You Most Excited For?