Turn off the Lights

Supergirl – Welcome to Earth

"The times they are alien "

After a twoepisode visit from the Man of Steel, Supergirl gets down to brass tacks by establishing the core themes for the show’s second season. Those themes are instantly familiar to anyone who’s followed the recent news cycle, except they come with a sci-fi twist—alien refugees come to this planet seeking asylum but don’t declare their presence on Earth in order to avoid persecution from a populace that fears and mistrusts them. Supergirl certainly isn’t breaking new ground in this regard—after all, the X-Men franchise is steeped in such identity politics. But with the presidential election just a few short weeks away, it’s not at all hard at all to see “Welcome to Earth” as a reflection and a commentary on these turbulent political times.

Among the more obvious nods to current events is that the Supergirl universe has a woman president, portrayed by Lynda Carter. This bit of stunt casting is both an Easter egg to comics nerds—Carter, of course, was Wonder Woman in the hit 70s series—and also throws a rhetorical bone to those who plan on voting for the first woman president this November. (Supergirl herself drives this point home with this not-so-subtle dig at the other candidate: “How did anyone vote for that other guy?”) Jessica Queller and Derek Simon, the writers of the “Welcome to Earth” episode, show its characters, Supergirl in particular, as philosophically aligned with Carter’s President Marsdin’s alien amnesty policy. However, her worldview gets challenged thanks to the introduction of two new alien characters: Mon-El (Chris Wood) and Scorcher (Nadine Crocker).

supergirl-welcome-to-earth-image-1

Because Mon-El is from Daxam, Supergirl has an immediate enmity towards him and thinks he’s responsible for the attempted assassination attempts on the president. The Hatfield-McCoy dynamic between Kryptonians and Daxamites in Supergirl is considerably different from the chummy relations the two sister races enjoy in the comics. But it’s a welcomed change, as it allows Queller and Simon to examine how social and political differences—for instance, Krypton is a democracy while Daxam is a monarchy—can lead to each side having a one-sided, negative perspective on the other. Correspondingly, both the writers and Wood take Mon-El in an interesting direction by making him a working-class version of Superboy (as opposed to the Mon-El from the comics who is barely distinguishable from Superboy himself). To its credit, the show doesn’t shy away from depicting Supergirl’s bigotry before ultimately having her realize the error of her ways. Not only does this character beat give balance to her generally pro-alien-rights viewpoint, it gives Kara a greater degree of depth by having her acknowledge and then overcome her own racism.

Supergirl’s prejudice towards Daxamites clouds her ability to recognize that the real assailant is the fire-manipulating Scorcher. (Curiously enough, the writers elected not to name her Volcana despite the fact that her look and powers are obviously indebted to that antagonist from the 90s Superman animated series). Scorcher’s motivations for attacking a President seemingly sympathetic to the alien cause resembles that of many dispossessed minorities: simply put, she distrusts the government’s intentions. As she says at one point in the episode, “Amnesty is just another mask for disguised registration.” That point of view, as legitimate as it may be, is never given the full consideration it should as Scorcher is depicted as a villain first and a passionate yet misguided activist second. We yet see that the President’s pro-amnesty stance has its flaws—and may even be self-interested, as we get a quick reveal of her alien form toward the end of the episode—but it’s disappointing that those ideas weren’t explored more fully.

supergirl-welcome-to-earth-image-2

With that said, “Welcome to Earth” does manage to cram in a good number of themes and characters, to the point that I’ve gotten this far in the review without mentioning the introduction of Floriana Lima as Detective Maggie Sawyer. As with Mon-El, the show adapts the basic template of the Maggie Sawyer character from the comics while adding an extra dimension that makes the character even stronger. In this case, Maggie is not only a lesbian but also a woman of color, thereby giving her two ways in which she feels affinity with the alien community. (One wonders if the showrunners designed this version of Maggie after another Latina lesbian from DC Comics, Renee Montoya, who appeared on Fox’s Gotham.) Moreover, Lima’s Maggie is simply more fun and dynamic than the fairly conservative DC Comics Maggie. There are even hints of a flirtatious relationship between her and Alex—who hasn’t had much romance aside from a brief dalliance with Max Lord—which would be quite the welcomed development from a diversity standpoint.

To its credit, “Welcome to Earth” takes an expanded view of the current situation rather than explicitly advocate for one side over another. By using the cloak of sci-fi allegory, a superhero show like Supergirl can be more impactful with its political commentary without explicitly alienating a particular demographic. At the same time, the show successfully introduces a panoply of fun characters and concepts—and that includes the Miss Martian cameo at the end of the episode—that serve as an escapist release for those looking to get away from reality for approximately 40 minutes (not including commercials). All things considered, you can’t ask for much more than that.

Rating
8.5
Pros
  • Introduction of characters from comics but with a twist (Mon-El, Maggie Sawyer)
  • Interesting take on today's issues with a fun superhero twist
Cons
  • Scorcher being treated as a disposable villain rather than a character with a valid political POV
  • Could stand to see less of old, sour Snapper Carr

Liked this article? Try These!

Comments

  • Irish Jim

    When I was a kid, long ago, I was a huge fan of the Legion of Super Heroes. in particular, I was a huge of Mon-el.

    To me, he was a more humble and more powerful version of Superboy. Brainiac 5’s serum had made him immune to lead (his weakness, not Kryptonite) and let him keep his powers under a red sun.

    Mon-el met Superboy and Superboy named him Mon-el as a mistake. Superboy thought Mon-el was Superboy’s brother and Mon-el had amnesia, so he couldn’t correct him.

    When Mon-el regained his memory, he realized his name was Lar Gand and that he was from Daxam.

    I really dislike the changes that Supergirl made to the story. He is no longer Lar Gand, but comes named Mon-el. Kara doesn’t bat an eye that he has the same family name that she has. Are they distant cousins?

    Daxam is a colony of Krypton where criminals were sent – Sounds like Australia or maybe Vulcan – Romulus from Star Trek.

    In the comic books he spent 1,000 years in the Phantom Zone until Brainac 5 came up with the cure to his lead poisoning. Is he headed to the Phantom Zone? Will they bring in the LSH and have him just leave for the future to find his way?

    So is Mon-el vulnerable to Kryptonite? Is he as powerful as Superman?

    Maybe they will surprise me and make this right. In Flash, they fixed Jay Garrick by the end of Season 2.

    I realized they will deviate from the comics and I also know that characters I grew up with have changed greatly in the last 30 years, but this was a big disappointment.

    I didn’t like the “alien menace” story-line, where all aliens except Superman and Supergirl are hunted. It seemed stupid not to find out their intentions first.

    This week’s turn where there are underground bars where aliens go to drink and relax seems just as odd. Do all these aliens come in ships that they hide? Are they stranded? It is sort of like Men in Black.
    The President is an alien? Really? It reminds me of the X Men movie where Mystique impersonated the senator and helped mutants or when Sylar took over the President on Heroes.

    They need to keep these stories fairly simple so people can follow them easily.

News from Around the Web

Meet the Author

Follow Us

Our Sponsors

Featured Poll

What is Your Favorite Game Franchise?
Yop Poll Widget
Which Upcoming Game Are You Most Excited For?