Fire Emblem Fates (Birthright, Conquest and Revelation) Review
"One game for the price of three"
When Intelligent Systems made Fire Emblem Awakening
a few years ago, they decided to make it the best installment yet. It wasn’t because they were pumped about making a new Fire Emblem
on the Nintendo 3DS or that there was a big marketing push for it, it was quite the opposite. See, throughout the years, Fire Emblem
was declining in popularity worldwide for some time, and Awakening
was sort of a send off to the franchise as a whole. What was supposed to be the final Fire Emblem
ended up becoming the best-selling version in the series’ 20+ year history by a wide margin. Since then, Fire Emblem
has gotten a push to become a bigger franchise in Nintendo’s catalog with a Atlus-developed spinoff for Wii U and another, more ambitious mainline successor for the 3DS: Fire Emblem Fates
Fire Emblem Fates
is a weird game to review because it’s three games that are being reviewed: Fire Emblem Fates: Birthright
, Fire Emblem Fates: Conquest
and Fire Emblem Fates: Revelation
, with each of them following a different “what if” scenario during a bitter war between two nations.
You follow Corrin, a customizable avatar much like Awakening’s
Robin, a princess (or prince, though she will be referred as a female in the review) of the Japanese-esque Hoshido that was kidnapped at a young age and raised with the royal family of the European-looking Nohr. Corrin learns of her Hoshidian backstory as well as her dragon origins after stumbling into the country, and with a more educated opinion must decide in front of both royal families which side to fight on.
Fire Emblem Fates: Birthright
is where Corrin chooses Hoshido over her known family in Nohr. There she joins her bloodline siblings Ryoma, Takumi, Sakura and Hinoka and stop Nohr’s King Garon (Your kidnapper/foster father) from invading Hoshido.
The story in Birthright
trumps the one in Conquest
because the land of Hoshido is one fresh and cool in the Fire Emblem
series. Normally Fire Emblem
characters look very medieval in tone, with knights, mages and thieves equipping swords, spears, knives, axes and using magical rods, Conquest included. Since Hoshido is Japanese in tone, characters look like those in feudal Japan with samurai, ninjas and shrine maidens wielding katanas, naginanas, shurikens and magical festals. Despite a few in-game traits, this change is mainly aesthetic, but it doesn’t stop looking cool in the process. In addition the locales in Hoshido are bright colorful and different to the series, while Nohr is bleak, dark, dreary and quite a downer in comparison. Granted, that’s the point of the two versions and their very different nations, but Hoshido not only look better, it’s exhilarating for the Fire Emblem
plays most like Fire Emblem Awakening
, and is the most recommended place to begin in the Fire Emblem Fates
trilogy. All the Fire Emblem Fates
games are grid-based strategy RPGs with the same exact gameplay mechanics and twenty-seven story chapters, Birthright
is the simpler of the bunch. Most of the goals within the Hoshido campaign are to defeat all the enemies on the map, and unlike Conquest
, you can replay stages and grind your party to your hearts desire. This one is the best to start for newcomers because it gets them used to the mechanics, while veterans can take care of the easiest one first since it’ll feel like a downgrade if you’re playing this one secondly.
Meanwhile Fire Emblem Fates: Conquest
is the other side of the story and Corrin sticks with her Nohrian brothers and sisters: Xander, Leo, Camilla and Elise. Returning from Hoshido, Corrin is tasked by King Garon to calm a revolution brewing in Nohr while conspiring to invade Hoshido to claim its throne to stop the true evil within the two kingdoms.
To be honest, playing Conquest
right after Birthright
was tough because reverting to the same old medieval theme after the breath of fresh air that was Hoshido. While that was true through most of the game, your allies, mainly your siblings and their loyalty to Corrin made me care about them despite dealing with them mere hours ago in Birthright
. Corrin is no slouch either, where Birthright
is more traditional “good guys defend against bad guys,” she has to endure some tough decisions in Conquest
while Garon and his ruthless retainers breathe down her back. Corrin also feels more like a leader as her siblings and allies follow her un-Nohr-like choices backed by trust; especially compared to Birthright
, where she continues the path Ryoma already started and performing nothing but common sense decisions.
, there are few battles in Conquest
where the sole goal is to rout the enemy. You will be retreating, fighting with time limits and sieging the base (which is only killing the boss and landing on their space to end the fight). These fights are rife with enemy reinforcements and difficult map terrain to cover too, and if that’s not enough, you cannot replay stages either. This limits what you can do throughout the twenty-seven chapters since it makes you have to think smartly and clearly when it comes many of the other gameplay elements like building relationships and the My Castle upgrades. Many who are not 100% in the know with Fire Emblem
may think that’s a bit of a down point, but this is classic Fire Emblem
choice-making. It’s only enhanced because many older Fire Emblems
didn’t have to worry about romancing characters or upgrading castles to benefit your party more, making this one the best to replay over again. I also say that because it’s the shortest one in the bunch thanks to the lack of time you have to do some extra bits.
The biggest issue with both the Birthright
scenarios is that they both represent a “bad” ending, where Corrin, allies and even the players themselves finish without feeling truly fulfilled. This was done on purpose thanks to planted plot holes as forced outcomes that left those involved with holes in their hearts. That’s where Fire Emblem Fates: Revelation
comes into play.
This downloadable-only expansion, outside the Special Edition, makes Corrin choose neither Hoshido nor Nohr, and decides to forge a different path. Both families then react harshly and disown you except Azura, a character that doubled as a plot device in the previous games, who now knows her (and your) true calling. This campaign mostly takes place in Valla, a different dimension altogether, where the true strings within Hoshido and Nohr are being pulled. Because Revelation
mainly focuses on filling plot holes versus exploring a world for the player to learn and adapt to, it should be the last of the three campaigns you should play.
Revelation contains the “best of both worlds” gameplay, where you have the heightened objectives of Conquest
while gaining the ability to take your time and grind in Birthright
. In addition, you have more allies in this version than the other two, so there’s an exclusive ability to romance characters normally impossible in other versions. If there’s a version to be your go-to Fire Emblem Fates
for StreetPass and multiplayer, it’s this one.
It’s annoying that Revelation
is exclusively DLC to those with Birthright
because its gameplay is really the definitive edition of the Fates
trilogy. It’s sad knowing it will be the path least explored because only in Revelation
did I feel like I’m playing the Fire Emblem
that Intelligent Systems created, not one that felt like 2/3 of one.
That’s not the same with the story however. Though none of the three Fates
are really going to win any Best Writing awards anytime soon, Valla’s locales and enemies are way kookier than the understandable, down-to-earth settings of Hoshido and Nohr. Even the final boss and corny ending kind of fell flat, with me shrugging my shoulders questioning if there was a bigger fight that was supposed to happen.
Like I mentioned before, Fire Emblem
are grid-based strategy RPG’s, where allies and enemies have their turn to place their characters in order to defeat one another.
Previous Fire Emblem
games have a rock-paper-scissors advantage system where certain weapons will have a slight advantage on others, and Fates
is no different. Luckily characters can change and upgrade their classes, allowing a better array of weapons to be equipped, so players can have unites carry multiple types of weapons and change them before each fight. It’s just another layer of strategy peppered onto the game that makes it more fun, but I do wished they kept the breakable weapons (more on that in a bit).
New to Fire Emblem Fates
is the Dragon Veins, special spots on the field where Corrin, her siblings or any of their kids can activate. These vary from drying rivers to neutralizing poisonous areas to creating windstorms to slow down particular units, and they get a bit more creative the further down the line. These are invaluable resources to give an edge in battle, though if you’re fighting a member of the royal family, they can use them too, making those fights in particular very interesting.
When people first research the Fire Emblem
series, one gameplay element that tends to excite/freak out the player is permadeath, where if a unit’s HP goes to zero, they are permanently removed from the campaign whether from death or, if they’re part of the main story, injured to the point of unusable on the field. Awakening
for the first time gave the option to remove that so that people can play at their own pace. It was a factor of the series’ resurgence of new players and they happily played without fear of being locked without a party.
While I scoffed at using it in Awakening
, I actually played with permadeath off in Fates. Maybe it’s to lower the stress of playing to just wanting to play through the campaigns in a faster pace, but I’m happy to do so because the Fates
trilogy feels brutal with it on, way more so than any other localized Fire Emblem
. I started with it on because I always had it in previous installments, but enemies seem to have a heightened AI as well as a higher critical hit rate to the point that I no longer wanted to deal with the consistent resets. Even after turning the option off, I refrained from rushing enemies and played tactfully, and I rarely left the field without a KO’d ally.
There’s a new mode in Fire Emblem Fates
for permadeath, Phoenix, which revives characters the next turn, which feels like overkill in the easy department.
Another Fire Emblem
staple that was heavily altered in Fire Emblem Fates
was the breakable weapons. Normally in the series, non-legendary weapons would have an HP gauge on them, decreasing by one with every hit. Once the HP goes to zero, the weapon breaks and players must adapt by having characters equip multiple swords or axes unless they want they character unarmed.
removes this element aside from staves for some reason or another, and it feels like a lesser Fire Emblem
because of it. I was always entering the battlefield examining if I need to shop for more swords, staves or axes and now only had to worry about healers. While it passed my mind throughout the games, in retrospect it was missed since it decreased a layer of strategy.
That doesn’t mean weapons should be upgraded without worry however, because the developers decided on punishing those craving extra damage with penalties to higher grade weapons with cutting stats like speed, defense or attack with every attack. To be honest, I vastly ignored the penalties and it rarely stopped the onslaught enemies were about to endure.
New to the Fire Emblem
games is a base where you hang out between battles. Dubbed My Castle, this area allows you to build and upgrade shops, upgrade weapons with smithies, interact with the characters in your army.
With a character base as large as Fire Emblem Fates
, it’s inevitable for fans to ship characters creating their own romances. Thankfully, Intelligent Systems actually made that a feature! Characters who fight and defend adjacent to one another will get closer and unlock some well-written conversations, which varies from funny to character building. After unlocking a few conversations between two characters, the option open to marry them and doing so can create a child based on the father, though carries the mother’s hair color as well as both parent’s skills. It’s a neat portion of the game that was carried over from Awakening
, and it forces the developers and the localizers to do their best creating characters unique, fun and captivating enough to make it worth doing, but some characters get too much into the super-otaku (weeaboo) territory with anime stereotypes like hot springs and maids (though they’re super useful). Though the thought process having the kids reappear as teenagers while the parents’ are still in their twenties is eye-rolling at best.
One other feature of My Castle is visiting other people’s castles. You can find those who recently updated, recommended ones, friends’ castles or those you get via StreetPass. They allow some perks like giving experience to your castle for leveling up and the ability to shop at stores not yet upgraded or available in yours. It gives a reason to care about yours since your castle could be visited at anytime. You can even fight the team of that castle to test yours, or fight within yours with invasions of CPU characters.
Fire Emblem Fates
also uses amiibo figures to add them to your army, but is relegated to the original four Fire Emblem
characters (sorry Roy). Scanning your Marth, Ike, Lucina and/or Robin figures a few times between fights allow them to meet Corrin, followed by the chance to unlock them as warriors by beating them in battle. Though for many Nintendo fans to actually do that, the company first needs to get more of those four on store shelves.
One of my biggest gripes with Fire Emblem Awakening
was the lack of multiplayer, but Fates
fortunately brings back the forgotten mode. Now you can play against anyone online with a decent selection of maps, both players’ My Castles included, in 5v5 battles. Granted it’s robust in Fire Emblem
standards, but unfortunately it isn’t in comparison to most other games out there, with 5v5 being the most severe limitation. After trying it for a bit, I was demanding more from the mode.
Fates As A Trilogy
With the discussion of the differences between the three versions, I can discuss the conclusion I have with Fire Emblem Fates
being developed as three separate games. Fates
was a nifty project with playing out how differently life can go when you make a big decision.
Normally I love these “butterfly effect” scenarios and how crazy that one thing can spiral to a whole new conclusion, but Nintendo wanted to deliver this game as three different experiences... and three different SKUs that are sold separately. While I’ll never think like a conspiracy theorist, I do feel like Nintendo is double-dipping the hardcore Nintendo fan by having them spend at least $80 to experience the three paths: One full version is $40 and the other path can be bought digitally as DLC for $20, and Revelation is only DLC for $20; or the Special Edition for $80 outright. That’s not counting the first bit of DLC maps at $18, with more to go.
My feeling behind that is because none of the three versions lasted as long as Fire Emblem Awakening
did singlehandedly. I put around 60-65 hours in the trilogy (about 22, 13 and 25 hours in Birthright
respectfully) and was able to beat the games, romance many of the characters and fool around with other things like the DLC maps (also sold separately). Awakening
clocked around eighty hours while doing about the same breadth of content. It bothers me because I dumped $80 to experience less than I did with Awakening’s $40.
Though this sounds very negative, let me say that I had fun throughout the trilogy thanks to its addictive gameplay and likable characters, I just wished all that could have been done without games with purposely missing elements and releveling the same characters thrice over. Plus, even at the $80 price point for the trilogy, I still feel like I spent enough time and play than I would with two traditional AAA console games.