Turn off the Lights

Game of Thrones – The Red Woman Review

"Exposition, with a hint of the fantastic"

Guess what, everyone? Jon Snow is really, most sincerely dead. Now that we have confirmed that what the cast, crew, and creative team behind Game of Thrones have been preaching since the end of Season 5 is true, let’s unpack the heaps of exposition we were given this week. Oh, and that really intriguing look at the real Melisandre, and what that might mean for the Red Woman herself moving forward.

I never go into a Game of Thrones season premiere expecting all that much in the way of interesting plot points or major story beats. Particularly at this point in the show’s run, it has become fairly clear that the season premiere is meant to take stock of where are major players are, both physically within the realm and mentally within their own personal journey. And, with “The Red Woman,” the show didn’t really veer all that far from the usual act of laying out the chess board for the upcoming season. We have more of the same in King’s Landing, with the Tyrells in dire straits, Cersei and Jamie mourning yet another child, and the Sparrows still holding (almost) all the cards (Ser Robert Strong is a solid plus in Cersei’s favor at this point). The Night’s Watch remains in a state of flux, as one might expect in light of yet another Lord Commander being taking out by his own men. And Ramsey and Roose Bolton remain at Winterfell with only the most tenuous hold over the North in light of the epic Sansa and Theon escape.

ep601_publicity_still_4_0010576211

As for Sansa and Theon, their situation was greatly improved with the (much delayed) arrival of Brienne. I have a sneaking suspicion it won’t be a reunion that lasts the entire season, as what would be the fun of that? (Answer: It would be great fun and I would love to watch Sansa, Brienne, and Pod traipse about the countryside, but since I would love that to happen, I’m almost certain it won’t come to pass. Also, take one gander at the last Season 6 trailer, and it becomes pretty clear that this reunion is only temporary.) But, I must admit, it was pretty darn great to see Sansa smile and not spend an episode cowering or crying. I’m 100% ready to experience a strong, badass Sansa Stark.

Speaking of badass Stark women, the brief glimpse we were given of Arya set up what I hope is a really quick arc with her blindness. Watching several weeks of Arya begging for money and trying to fight off the Waif will get really old, really fast. I have enough faith in the show’s creative team to trust that they know this particular arc is a bit of a dead end for one of their most beloved characters, and it will turn out to only be a blip on the radar this season. But, on the other hand, if the goal of the Waif’s actions is to train Arya to listen and not simply react, I can’t see her picking up that particular talent overnight (nor do I see Arya mastering blind fighting by the end of episode two). So, I worry this story may drag out longer than necessary, which would be a shame.

GoT-11

It also seems that the writers enjoyed last season’s foray into Dorne just as much as their audience. With the Sand Snake coup, I’m not really sure what the point of Dorne even is now. Are we to assume that the entire Dornish Army is behind Ellaria Sand? It certainly appeared that she had taken control of at least the palace guards. But what is her goal? To sail to King’s Landing and destroy the Lannisters? They seems to be doing a pretty solid job of that all on their own, thank you very much. The failings of the Dorne storytelling from Season 5 were on full display during the episode’s brief stopover there this week, as I couldn’t tell which Sand Snake was which (“the woman from Whale Rider and the other one” was how I personally told them apart). Had the show taken the time to explore these potentially interesting characters more last year, perhaps this development might have felt more organic and less of an attempt to turn Dorne into a place we should care about.

Finally, I want to touch on the episode’s one truly intriguing moment: the reveal of the real Melisandre. There have been hints throughout the series that Melisandre is significantly older than one might think at first glance. But I certainly never though the show would offer us a chance to see what she was really made of. For a series that so frequently trades in the nudity of its attractive cast (Season 6 guest star Ian McShane summed up the show as “just tits and dragons” in a recent interview), it was quite the change to see a beautiful character stripped of that beauty and revealed to be the exact opposite of the glamour and poise she represents to the outside world. Melisandre can, on occasion, be a tad one note as a character. But seeing that, beyond her magic (and she most certainly does possess magic), Melisandre is frail and weak, was quite the eye opener. I feel a deeper connection to the character than I ever expected to feel. There’s far more underneath the surface of the Red Woman than I thought, and I desperately want to continue to learn what makes her tick. And whether or not she plans on using the power she clearly possesses to bring the good Lord Commander back from the dead.

tumblr_inline_o666a6MC9Q1qbdfh0_1280

Final Thoughts:

— While Dany might not be particularly thrilled to be venturing back into the land of the Dothraki, I’m glad we don’t have to deal with another female character getting raped on the show. At least not this week.

— I still want to pitch a buddy spin-off of Varys and Tyrion just hanging out in cities and matching wits. In fact, if nothing else save that happened this season, I would deem it a success.

— There will be a number of think pieces written about the show’s use of nudity in that final scene, written by people with a great deal more knowledge in the world of gender politics than I. But I do want to commend the series for showing something that is almost never seen in big budget Hollywood fare: a naked woman who isn’t young and gorgeous, whose nudity was essential to the scene. Melisandre constantly uses her looks and her body to titillate (and the show uses her body for the same reason). Turning the tables on the audience after appearing to show Melisandre once again using her looks for her own gain was pretty brilliant.

— Glad to see that everyone’s favorite “Shame!” Septa is back again this year.

Rating
8.0
Pros
  • Set the chess board for the season
  • No one was screaming or crying, for once
  • Really interesting Melisandre reveal
Cons
  • Worry that Arya's storyline might drag

Liked this article? Try These!

Comments

  • Irish Jim

    There are a lot of story lines going on and they didn’t even get to Bran and the Iron Born. They really need to streamline these stories.

    I don’t like the religious story line in Kings Land Landing. It is hard to believe that the Army couldn’t put down the religious revolt pretty quickly. I also have a hard time believing the Tyrells wouldn’t be doing more about Margaery and Loras being locked up by the clergy.

    Right now on the show, none of the other Kingdoms are secure.

    Dorne is in open revolt.

    Highgarden has to be furious at the treatment of its prince and princess.

    The Riverlands are not subdued – Jamie went to Dorne instead. Littlefinger is breaking free in the Eyrie

    The Boltons want to break free in the North.

    The Iron Born are probably going to be doing something. In the Books they sent someone to try to bring back Danerys to marry the King of the Iron Islands. Since Danerys is not where she is supposed to be, I wonder how they will adjust this story.

    At some point they need to deal with dragons and White Walkers. They seem a long way from getting that done.

    I didn’t like how quickly and easily they killed Doran Martell and Areo Hotah. Areo was arguably the best fighter in the story and they killed him with a small knife to the back.

    I

News from Around the Web

Meet the Author

About / Bio
TV critic based in Chicago. When not watching and writing about awesome television shows, I can be found lamenting over the latest disappointing performance by any of the various Chicago sports teams or my beloved Notre Dame Fighting Irish. Follow me @JeaniusIsMe on Twitter.

Follow Us

Our Sponsors

Featured Poll

What is Your Favorite Game Franchise?
Yop Poll Widget
Which Upcoming Game Are You Most Excited For?